Property taxes can be a significant expense for homeowners, especially as home values fluctuate. However, a way to legally reduce your tax burden is by disputing your home’s valuation. In this guide, I’ll walk you through how to challenge the City’s house evaluation and potentially save thousands of dollars each year.
Understanding Property Taxes
Property taxes are based on your home’s estimated value, which is multiplied by your area’s property tax rate. For example, in Seattle, Washington, the property tax rate is roughly 1%. If your home is valued at $1 million, your annual property tax bill would be around $10,000. However, each city or county has its rates, and these taxes can vary based on your house location and other factors.
How is Your Home’s Valuation Determined?
Each year, local authorities (your city or county) issue home valuation reports based on the average sale prices of homes in your area. These valuations are often generated automatically, relying on past years’ sales data. However, it doesn’t always reflect the true value of every home. For example, older homes or properties with unique features may be overvalued if they are compared to newer or more modern homes in the same area.
Why Dispute Your Home’s Valuation?
Homeowners receive a notice from their city or county each year with their property’s assessed value. If you believe this value is too high, you have the right to appeal it. Successfully disputing your valuation could lower your property taxes significantly. Though this might sound complicated, the process is straightforward and can result in substantial savings.
In one of my recent experiences, my home was initially valued at $849,000, but the city increased the valuation to $1.13 million. By gathering data on nearby homes that sold for less, I was able to argue that the valuation was too high. For example, I found a nearby home that sold for $750,000 and another that sold for $770,000, both with similar features to my home. Using this evidence, I successfully lowered the valuation to $900,000, saving over $2,000 in property taxes that year.
Here are Steps to Dispute Your Home’s Valuation
- Gather Comparable Sales Data: Use websites like Zillow or Redfin to find homes in your area that are similar to yours. Look for homes that sold within the last year and have similar characteristics, such as square footage, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, and the age of the home.
- Focus on Recent Sales: Ensure that the sales data you collect is from the same period used for your current valuation. For example, if you’re disputing your 2024 valuation, gather data from homes sold in 2023.
- Prepare a Comparable Sales List: Once you’ve found five to ten comparable homes, create a list that includes each home’s sale price, size, and features. This will serve as evidence in your appeal. Make sure the homes you choose are priced within your expectations.
- Submit Your Appeal: Each city or county has a different process for submitting an appeal. Most allow you to file online or via mail. In your appeal, you’ll need to provide your property’s details, its current assessed value, the value you believe is accurate, and the reasons for your appeal. Be sure to include the comparable sales data you gathered to support your case.
Disputing your home’s valuation is not only possible but also worthwhile. The entire process can be completed in a couple of hours and may save you thousands of dollars in property taxes annually. If you have any questions about property taxes or the dispute process, feel free to leave a comment or reach out directly!
Don’t forget to like and share this blog if you found it helpful.